Marco Lo Blanco (Nanuk Asset Management) and Jason Petras (Resonant Asset Management) discuss the challenges and future of active management in managed account portfolios
Active asset allocation has been largely responsible for the majority of returns in investor portfolios for a number of years. However, more recently, there has been a noticeable decline of active management in Australia, driven by a combination of underperformance against major benchmarks, market concentration, and the growth of low-cost passive and superannuation options.
Despite this backdrop, Marco Lo Blanco, CFA — Portfolio Manager and Head of Research at Nanuk Asset Management — remains bullish on active management, saying it still earns its place in portfolio management, but perhaps not in the role it traditionally played.

By Jayson Forrest
Ian Knox
Private Equity Investor

Jason Petras
VDirector, Investments
Resonant Asset Management

Marco Lo Blanco, CFA
Head of Research
Nanuk Asset Management

Continued.....
In a session titled ‘Does traditional active management still earn its place?’ at the 2026 IMAP Independent Thought Conference, Marco acknowledges that the recent widespread underperformance of active fundamental equity managers (who specifically rely on bottom-up fundamental research to pick stocks), isn’t just the function of market concentration, but also the result of structural changes happening in the economy, across portfolios, and markets.
Traditional sources of alpha have shrunk, systematic strategies are competing for what is left, and trends are less persistent. It has become far more difficult to combine a set of active strategies based around different factors to achieve a consistently style neutral approach and outcome
Significant structural changes
Nanuk believes the global economy is currently undergoing significant structural changes that are likely to continue in the decades ahead. These changes are increasingly impacting portfolios, and include sector composition changes to asset classes (like global equities) and portfolio construction.
Sector composition changes: According to Marco, the first structural change occurring is sector composition changes to global equities. He says there has been a clear and accelerating shift towards electronic technologies, technology services, and producer manufacturing sectors.
These three sectors have increased in weight from 16 per cent in 2009, to over 40 per cent of the total global equities composition today, effectively replacing sectors like finance, energy minerals, and consumer non-durables, which have traditionally been large weights in value strategies.
“As the global economy changes, these changes are creating inefficiencies that skilful active managers can exploit,” says Marco.
Portfolio construction: The second structural change is in portfolio construction. Marco says 20 years ago, Australian equities represented the majority of growth assets in a typical Australian investor’s portfolio, while international equities were mostly a blend of active fundamental managers, with value and growth combined to neutralise style biases and capture manager skill.
However, today, the average allocation of Australian equities has been reduced in favour of international equities, with that exposure shifted towards low-fee passive and more recently, quantitative strategies.
Quantitative strategies use mathematical models, statistical analysis, and computer algorithms to make and execute investment decisions. Instead of relying on human intuition or qualitative judgments (like company management quality or news headlines), quant strategies depend on hard data — such as historical prices, trading volumes, macroeconomic indicators, and alternative datasets.
“As a result, the use of traditional active managers has shrunk significantly, which has resulted in fewer funds being used,” says Marco. “Fee pressure and a lower tolerance for underperformance — driven by initiatives like Your Future, Your Super — has driven much of this.”
The expectation from investors is, if they’re going to pay an active manager, they want to see some alpha. However, I believe that has had an impact on too much risk being taken by some managers. That’s because you’ve got very large amounts of money chasing a smaller pool of alpha
Return on equity
When looking at the overall economy, Marco says growth has slowed, regulation has increased across many industries, and economic shocks have become more frequent, which all weigh on market returns. At the same time, he acknowledges that new business models can still grow at high returns with very little capital required.
“For about 50 years, the S&P 500’s return on equity moved on a long run average of about 14 per cent. Over the last 10 years, this has risen to over 20 per cent. This has been driven by structurally more profitable companies. Meanwhile, the ASX 200 Financials’ return on equity has declined under heavy regulation and capital requirements.”
Marco says this is an important consideration, because over the long-term, market returns are mainly driven by return on equity and how much of that is reinvested. So, while cyclicality and mean reversion still exist, the historical averages of these are shifting. That’s a problem for active strategies built on mean reversion, particularly value stocks and small cap stocks.
“It’s a big part of why the ASX 200 has returned about 10 per cent per year over the past decade, compared to about 15 per cent for global developed markets,” says Marco. “Unless profitability recovers, there is little reason to expect that gap to close. A return to value outperforming would need a recovery in its underlying profitability and so far, there is little evidence of that happening.”
Blending value, growth, and quality to achieve style neutrality has become impractical for most portfolios. Instead, use active strategies for their biases, not combined to cancel them out. Blending works only with full look-through to holdings and frequent rebalancing. So, choose each strategy for a defined role in the total portfolio
Other challenges for active management
Marco adds there has also been some significant structural changes in equity markets that present challenges for active management. These include:
1. Information — Data is far more available today than anytime previously. It travels faster and markets are cheaper to access. Today’s data is able to support more sophisticated quant strategies, with news priced in faster. “The drift in share prices after earnings announcements, once a reliable source of alpha, have largely disappeared amongst big U.S. stocks.”
2. Flows — Passive investing ETFs, algorithmic and retail trading, now drive much more activity, and are often unrelated to fundamentals.
3. Ownership — More value is now created in the private market before companies list, while the index remains concentrated in large U.S. technology companies.
“The result of these changes have been contradictory,” says Marco. “In the first half of 2026, the spread between winning and losing stocks reached levels last seen during the GFC. Yet, only around 4-in-10 global stocks beat the index.
“Traditional sources of alpha have shrunk, systematic strategies are competing for what is left, and trends are less persistent. It has become far more difficult to combine a set of active strategies based around different factors (like momentum, growth, value, and low volatility) to achieve a consistently style neutral approach and outcome.”
Marco believes the challenge around investing is made even harder by manager behaviour. He says there is a tendency for value and growth managers to drift in style, regardless of the relative performance of growth and value. “So, a value and growth manager can end up looking much more alike than their label suggests,” he says.
Another challenge identified by Marco revolves around traditional style-based strategies, which are becoming increasingly blurred. He says many stocks (like Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet, and Salesforce) are often also held in funds or indices defined as growth, value and quality all at the same time. “Blending funds of different styles isn’t delivering the diversification it once did,” says Marco.
The expectation from investors is, if they’re going to pay an active manager, they want to see some alpha. However, I believe that has had an impact on too much risk being taken by some managers. That’s because you’ve got very large amounts of money chasing a smaller pool of alpha
A multi-polar world
Jason Petras — Director, Investments at Resonant Asset Management — agrees that active management has its challenges, as it adapts to a multi-polar world, where managers have had to readjust to fast-shifting, macro dynamics. He adds that being able to measure risk in that environment is becoming increasingly important.
When thinking about active management, Jason believes there are five core areas that managers need to consider. They are:
1. Build resilient portfolios that can withstand shocks, rather than relying on a single economic outcome.
2. Understand what drives portfolio returns and risks, particularly in relation to how changing inflation, interest rates and credit conditions affect investments.
3. Identify asymmetric risks, where the potential downside materially outweighs the expected reward.
4. Have a plan for when conditions change, rather than trying to understand what just happened. “You need to know your next move in advance,” he says.
5. Know what to avoid. Avoiding crowded trades and excessive risks can be just as valuable as identifying the next winner.
“At Resonant, we do believe there is an overall shift to a multi-polar world. There is fragmentation around global supply chains, which we believe will continue. And there is greater fiscal and monetary uncertainty,” says Jason.
“So, for us, it’s about how all these issues flow through into dynamic asset allocation. We’re looking at sector and style exposures, we’re looking at duration across the fixed income spectrum, and FX hedging is also a key part of our approach. We also consider potential breakdowns or reversals of long-term relationships, like bond-equity correlations, which is something we keep a very close eye on within regimes (specific market or economic environments, such as high-inflation).”
Jason believes active managers today are genuinely focused on active management. He points to active equity and large cap managers, which in Australia, have been significantly disrupted by ETFs and industry funds (with their own in-house capability), and the ability to access cheap beta. This has resulted in managers in the large cap space moving more to concentrated equity portfolios.
“That’s because the expectation from investors is, if they’re going to pay an active manager, they want to see some alpha. However, I believe that has had an impact on too much risk being taken by some managers. That’s because you’ve got very large amounts of money chasing a smaller pool of alpha,” says Jason.
Beware of concentration risk
However, with FAANG stocks (Meta Platforms, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, and Alphabet/Google) accounting for approximately 20 per cent of the S&P 500 and nearly 40 per cent of the Nasdaq 100 index, Marco agrees stock concentration is a definite risk for active management.
He says the concentration levels today are almost unprecedented from a portfolio construction perspective, and are likely to continue to rise with the impending listing of a couple of large companies in the United States. However, he acknowledges that the growth of the big end of town (particularly in the U.S.) remains attractive to investors, with businesses in the U.S. continuing to grow at 15-25 per cent.
Jason believes with the inherent risk that stock concentration brings to a portfolio, the market can expect to see a move towards more active stock selection.
“Active stock selection does provide managers with access to more opportunities. However, it does come back to risk management,” says Jason. “Active stock selection needs to be done in a smart way. You can’t go all in on those trades, because it exposes you to catastrophic concentration risk if the company or sector hits an unexpected downturn.”
Key considerations for active management
When thinking about global equities and the role of active management in portfolio construction today, Marco points to two key considerations:
1. Fundamental active alpha has become harder to deliver. That’s because markets are more efficient, quant funds capture more of the traditional alpha, regimes change faster, industry economics are shifting, and more value is created before companies even list.
“Traditional active fundamental management has become more difficult and certain approaches have better chances of success,” he says. “The strategies most likely to succeed in today’s environment focus on alpha sources others aren’t capturing, such as: long-term structural changes that can’t be predicted from backward-looking data, capacity-constrained strategies, and situations where managers influence outcomes.”
2. Blending styles for neutrality is no longer practical. That’s due to faster style rotation, manager style drift, and style overlap at the stock level.
“Blending value, growth, and quality to achieve style neutrality has become impractical for most portfolios,” says Marco. “Instead, use active strategies for their biases, not combined to cancel them out. Blending works only with full look-through to holdings and frequent rebalancing. So, choose each strategy for a defined role in the total portfolio.”
According to Marco, active global equity strategies still earn a place in managed accounts, but in specific roles — such as distinct alpha sources (where managers take unique, high-conviction positions to generate extra returns that an index fund cannot replicate), tactical allocations (short to medium-term shifts in a portfolio to take advantage of current market trends or economic conditions), and/or as total portfolio diversifiers (spreading money out to reduce risk).
“So, while active management definitely deserves its place in portfolio management, it’s probably not in the role it traditionally played,” says Marco.
About
Marco Lo Blanco, CFA is Portfolio Manager and Head of Research at Nanuk Asset Management; and
Jason Petras is Director, Investments at Resonant Asset Management.
They spoke on the topic ‘Does traditional active management still earn its place?’ at the 2026 IMAP Independent Thought Conference.
The session was moderated by Ian Knox — Private Equity Investor.